Log Out
    • About
    • Join
    • Donate
    • Shop
SIGN OUT
Icon Profile
Icon Shopping Cart 0
Logo
  • NEWS
    • Weekly Newsletter
    • Podcast
    • Press Releases
    • Sheep Industry News
      • Past Issues
    • Video
  • EVENTS
    • Calendar
    • Past Convention Presentations
    • Future Meeting Dates
    • Submit An Event
  • ISSUES
    • Call to Action
    • ASI Positions
    • Congressional Contacts
    • Government Programs
      • Wildlife Services
      • Wool LDP
      • Lamb Buys
      • Disaster Assistance
      • Livestock Assistance
  • Producer Education & Information
    • Online Education
      • SSQA
      • LRP-Lamb
      • Scrapie
    • Research
      • Sheep & Goat Research Journal
      • Sheep Cost of Production Study
      • Productivity of Ewes on Range
      • 2013 WERA-39
      • Research Symposium Proceedings
      • 2005 Hairsheep Symposium
      • 2013 Parasite Control Conference
      • Sheep Production Survey Results (2009)
    • Animal Care & Welfare
    • Animal Health
      • Scrapie
      • Parasite Mngt
      • Biosecurity
      • MUMS
      • NAHMS
      • Antibiotics
    • Industry Information
      • Livestock Protection Dogs
      • Sheepherders
      • Animal Identification
    • Wool Quality Program
    • Scholarship
    • Awards
  • RESOURCE CENTER
    • Market Reports
      • USDA Weekly
      • ASI Weekly Market Report
      • Replacement Sheep Report
      • Packers & Stockyards Report
      • Historical Market Data
      • LRP-Lamb Report
      • NASS Reports
      • Livestock Marketing
      • Export Information
    • Publications
      • Sheep Care Guide
      • SSQA
      • Research, Education Priorities 2016
      • Economic Impact Analysis
      • Nontraditional Market Study
      • ASI Wool Journal
    • Materials
      • Best Practices Fact Sheets
      • Fast Facts
      • About Wool
      • Breed Directory
      • Targeted Grazing
      • Sheep and the Environment
      • About Pelts
      • For Kids
    • Allied Organizations
      • Industry Roadmap
      • ALB Nominations
      • NSIIC Nominations
    • Let's Grow Resources
  • CONTACTS
    • Industry
      • Breed Assns
      • Market Reporting
      • SSQA Trainers
      • Allied Organizations
      • Industry Assns
    • State
      • State Sheep Assns
      • Department of Agriculture
      • State Veterinarians
      • Extension Veterinarians
      • Extension Offices
      • Wildlife Services
    • Lamb Contacts
      • Commercial Packers
      • Commercial Fabricators
      • Other Lamb Suppliers
      • Auction Barns
    • Wool & Pelt
      • Shearer Directory
      • Wool Classers
      • Wool Pools
      • Research & Testing
      • Warehouses
      • Wool Buyers
      • First Stage Wool Processors
      • Large Order Commercial Resources
      • Small Custom Order Resources
Wide Sheep Sunrays
July 2015
  • July 2015
    • President's Notes
    • H-2A Comments Come From Variety of Sources in Industry
    • Iowa Gets Wild & Wooly at 11th Sheep & Wool Show
    • Let's Grow Grants Funded
    • Market Report
    • ASI Photo Contest
    • Legislative News in Brief
    • Trailing Festival Makes Plans
    • Montana Program to Discuss Genetics
    • ATHM Offers New Wool Exhibit
    • Sheep News in Brief
    • Wool News in Brief
    • The Last Word

H-2A Comments Come From Variety of Sources in Industry

Wool and sheepskin companies, bankers, shearers, textile companies and allied businesses united with sheep producers from across the country asking the Department of Labor to withdraw the wage formulation for H-2A sheepherders and replace it with a new method that is sustainable for sheepherders, the industry and the sheepherder program. 

“We count 484 comments filed to the Department of Labor’s proposed rule,” said Peter Orwick, ASI executive director. “There are many eloquent statements and solid points about the serious impacts and problems of the rule.” 

Nearly all commenters also spoke to the troubling proposal that ranches would be ineligible to hire herders if the sheep were required to spend half the year or more outside the sight of a fence or livestock facility.

Political appointees and elected officials also signed their names in support of the sheep industry. Sens. Mike Enzi (Wyo.), Cory Gardner (Colo.), Steve Daines (Mont.) and Heidi Heidkamp (N.D.), Reps. Cynthia Lummis (Wyo.), Ken Buck (Colo.) and Mark Amodei (Nev.) and Wyoming Gov. Matthew Mead commented alongside several county commissioners, the State of Utah and the state agriculture departments of Wyoming and New Mexico. Several sheep publications, six state Farm Bureau associations, many state sheep associations and the National Lamb Feeders Association also submitted comments asking for changes. 

“In reviewing the comments, it was interesting to note the level of dependency two lamb companies with hundreds of millions of dollars in annual sales and hundreds of employees have on sheep production under the care of H-2A herders. Comments quoted that 60 to 65 percent of all their lamb processing is ultimately reliant on the herder program,” said Orwick. “If the program is unaffordable or unavailable to the ranchers, then lambs will not be available for these companies. Approximately 38 percent of all sheep in America are under the watch of an H-2A sheepherder so we are not surprised that companies are just as threatened by the rule as ranchers.” 

The comment period is now closed and the DOL will spend as much as three months in the review and redraft process. 
The following is a summary of the full, eight-page comment submitted jointly by ASI and the Public Lands Council to the Department of Labor concerning proposed changes to H-2A .

ASI is the national trade organization representing the interests of more than 79,500 sheep producers located throughout the United States. PLC is the only national organization dedicated solely to representing the roughly 22,000 ranchers who hold grazing rights on federal lands.

Changes to the H-2A sheepherder program, therefore, would have a significant negative impact on the sheep industry and all related businesses – lamb processors, wool warehouses, textile mills, trucking and feed companies, veterinarians, fencing businesses and, most importantly, on the 79,500 family farms and ranches that raise sheep in America. 

The U.S. Department of Labor was not required by the courts to change the special procedures of the sheepherder and livestock worker programs, however, it has proposed to do so. ASI’s comments focused on two of the top changes in the proposal – wage and job definition. These two changes, as proposed, will mean that most of the sheep ranches employing H-2A herders today will find the program unaffordable or unavailable to them in 2016. Sheep-producer reactions to the proposed wage, and our economic analysis of it, concludes the expense is not sustainable for ranches to continue in the sheep business. 

The sheep on these ranches must be herded. If left to themselves, the sheep would be killed by predators, lost to disease/starvation or not recoverable by the rancher. However, there is no alternative to the H-2A sheepherder as American workers have declined to herd sheep for a living since the 1950’s. Also, there is no current pool of American workers who are trained in the specialty of herding sheep. 

Therefore, if there are no H-2A herders on U.S. ranches – for lack of any alternatives – the sheep will be sold. History demonstrated this in the case of the National Wool Act, which was phased out by the federal government in 1993-95. Tens of thousands of sheep ranches subsequently went out of production and millions of breeding sheep were disposed of when they could not budget a profit on their operation. In the late 1990s, linked allied industries followed the sheep producers by also going out of business as the lack of lamb, wool and customers forced them out.

We request the department withdraw the proposed wage methodology and replace it with a version that addresses the base-wage stagnation of the past 20 years yet at a rate that sustains the H-2A sheepherders and sheepherder program, as well as the sheep industry.

ASI provided input to the development of the two-wage methodologies contained in the comments of the Western Range Association and Mountain Plains Agricultural Service, and ask full consideration of adoption by the DOL.
 

“Open Range” and “Limits on Incidental” Work (Job Definition) 

The second critical issue for which we provide comment is the job definition of a sheepherder as proposed in 20 C.F.R. § 201 (proposed); 80 Fed. Reg. 20339.

The proposal suggests that no fences would be allowed in connection with sheepherders and, further, half of the herders’ year must be spent away from the ranch headquarters and livestock facilities. 

ASI’s membership, and that of the WRA and MPAS, indicate a majority of sheep operations would not be eligible to hire H-2A herders under this scenario. California sheep operations are a great example of this impact as they utilize targeted grazing under temporary fencing to reduce fire danger on a wide variety of forage from federal grazing allotments, private-native and -crop pastures and leased grasslands.

We asked the department to update their description of sheepherder duties and the management of sheep production to “Grazing Livestock Production System.” 

Orwick encourages readers to visit Sheepusa.org’s Legislative Action Center to view the full comments, as well as the extended comments of MPAS and WRA.

“Rather than just point out problems, we provided alternatives that will work,” Orwick said. “The Department of Labor will spend the next two months preparing the final rule that it will publish in November (or earlier) per direction of the federal courts.”

ASI

ASI keeps sheep industry members updated on ASI activities and industry news by regularly distributing and updating various information pieces and sources.

Icon FacebookIcon TwitterLogo Lets Grow

Contact Us

  • American Sheep Industry Association
  • 9785 Maroon Circle
  • Suite 360
  • Englewood, CO 80112
  • 303-771-3500
Subscribe to our Newsletter
Thank you for subscribing

Our team will email you with further information

Photo Stream

International

Flag Spain Espanol
Flag China 中国的
USDA FAS Foreign Agricultural Service
Ad Rates Classifieds Disclaimer Non-Discrimination Statement Copyright 2014 American Sheep Industry Association